Book No. –  23 (Western Political Thought)

Book Name The Social Contract and The First and Second Discourses (Jean-Jacques Rousseau)

What’s Inside the Chapter? (After Subscription)

Note: The first chapter of every book is free.

Access this chapter with any subscription below:

  • Half Yearly Plan (All Subject)
  • Annual Plan (All Subject)
  • Political Science (Single Subject)
  • CUET PG + Political Science
  • UGC NET + Book Notes
LANGUAGE

The Second Discourse: Discourse on the Origin and Foundations of Inequality Among Mankind

Picture of Harshit Sharma
Harshit Sharma

Alumnus (BHU)

Follow
Table of Contents
  • The discourse addresses man and speaks directly to men who are not afraid to honor truth and discuss difficult topics.

  • Two types of inequality among men are distinguished:

    • Natural or physical inequality: differences in age, health, bodily strength, mind, and soul qualities; established by nature.

    • Moral or political inequality: depends on convention and is established or authorized by common consent; includes privileges such as being richer, more honored, more powerful, and having the right to demand obedience from others.

  • It is pointless to ask about the cause of natural inequality, as it is self-explanatory by definition.

  • It is absurd to question if those who command are inherently better than those who obey, or if strength, wisdom, or virtue always correspond to power or riches.

  • Such questions are suitable for slaves but unbecoming free and rational beings pursuing truth.

  • The purpose is to identify the historical moment when right replaced violence, nature became subject to law, and the strong began to serve the weak.

  • The people traded imaginary ease for real happiness.

  • Philosophers have tried to trace society’s origins back to a state of nature, but none have truly reached it.

  • Many philosophers wrongly attribute justice and injustice or natural rights to men in that state without proof or explanation.

  • Some unjustly assume the strong have authority over the weak and immediately create government without considering how people would understand authority and government.

  • Philosophers confuse ideas from society with those that could exist in the state of nature, describing savages as citizens.

  • Few doubt that a state of nature existed, though sacred history suggests that even the first man, guided by God, never lived in such a state.

  • If one accepts the Books of Moses as credible, one must deny the actual existence of the state of nature before the Deluge unless by extraordinary event — a paradox difficult or impossible to prove.

  • The inquiry will set aside historical facts; these are hypothetical reasonings to illustrate nature’s laws rather than true origins.

  • Religion commands belief that men are unequal by God’s will but does not forbid conjectures based on human nature and surrounding beings about mankind’s fate if left to itself.

  • The discourse will use universal language, addressing all nations equally, imagining speaking before the philosophers of Athens and all humanity.

  • The account is read not from man-made books, which are lies, but from the book of nature, which never lies.

  • The times described are very remote; mankind has changed greatly from what it once was.

  • The narrative is like writing the life of the species, focusing on innate qualities, and on how education and habits have corrupted but not destroyed them.

  • There is an age at which every individual would choose to stop; the reader will seek the age at which mankind would have wished to stop its development.

  • Discontent with the present condition, which threatens unhappy posterity with greater troubles, may cause a wish to return to the past.

  • This sentiment is a praise of the first ancestors, a criticism of contemporaries, and a warning to future generations.

Membership Required

You must be a member to access this content.

View Membership Levels

Already a member? Log in here

You cannot copy content of this page

error: Content is protected !!
Scroll to Top