Concept of Equality
Chapter 17
(OP Gauba | Political Theory)
POLITICAL SCIENCE
Language Choose your preferred language
Concept of Equality
🎨 Reading Colors
Background
Text Color
Table of Contents
  • IDEA OF EQUALITY
  • EQUALITY AS A STATEMENT OF RIGHT, NOT OF FACT
  • EQUALITY AS A MODERN IDEA
  • EQUALITY AS AN IDEA OF SOCIAL CHANGE
  • EQUALITY DOES NOT IMPLY LITERAL EQUALITY
  • EQUALITY OF OPPORTUNITY
  • RATIONAL GROUNDS OF DISCRIMINATION
  • SPECIAL PROVISION IN THE CASE OF NEED
  • SPECIAL REWARD FOR EXCELLENCE
  • DEBATE ON REVERSE DISCRIMINATION
  • DIMENSIONS OF EQUALITY
  • FORMAL AND SUBSTANTIVE EQUALITY
  • LEGAL EQUALITY
  • POLITICAL EQUALITY
  • SOCIO-ECONOMIC EQUALITY
  • SIMPLE AND COMPLEX EQUALITY
  • LIBERTY AND EQUALITY
  • LIBERTY AND EQUALITY AS COMPLEMENTARY PRINCIPLES
  • IDEA OF EQUALITY AS IMPEDIMENT TO LIBERTY
  • CONCLUSION
  • EQUALITY AND JUSTICE

IDEA OF EQUALITY

  • Equality, like liberty, is a prominent political ideal in the contemporary world.
  • The French Revolution (1789) was fought for the ideals of liberty, equality, and fraternity.
  • Liberty and equality, together, describe the conditions for human emancipation.
  • These principles represent the voice of the oppressed, stand against injustice, and advocate for changing unfair social conditions.
  • In some contexts, liberty and equality are seen as complementary principles, while in others, they may seem mutually contradictory.
  • Understanding the nature and essence of equality is crucial to determining its relationship with liberty and justice.
  • The issue of equality and inequality has been central in political thought since ancient times.
  • Aristotle noted that inequality causes rebellion in states and defined justice as "treating equals equally and  unequals unequally."
  • Aristotle's view supported maintaining existing inequalities in society, such as between master and slave, rich and poor, and morally superior and inferior.
  • The modern concept of equality seeks to reduce inequalities that can be proven unjust based on prevailing social consciousness.

EQUALITY AS A STATEMENT OF RIGHT, NOT OF FACT

  • The modern idea of equality is derived from the theory of rights.
  • Equality is a prescriptive term, meaning it advocates for how men should be treated as equal, not that they are actually equal.
  • The argument for equality is often based on human rationality and the belief that all men are endowed with reason or created equal by God.
  • Another argument for equality is that physical, emotional, and intellectual needs are similar for all men, entitling them to equal rights.
  • Equality does not claim all men are equal in terms of physical or mental capacities, beauty, or talents.
  • The argument of common human attributes, such as the similarity of blood, is used to support equality.
  • Nature does not create differences in people; for example, a drug affects everyone the same, regardless of race.
  • Fundamental equality refers to the inherent equality among all human beings based on shared characteristics.
  • Some argue that equality does not derive support from nature, unlike liberty, because nature creates inequalities (sun and moon, rich and poor, strong and weak, etc.).
  • These arguments against equality often stem from those who wish to preserve their privileged position.
  • Such critics argue that liberty enables individuals to acquire wealth, power, and prestige, while equality diminishes these achievements.
  • This argument is based on a distorted concept of liberty: freedom in society must be equal freedom for all.
  • Absolute liberty would result in the strong oppressing the weak; liberty must be qualified by equality.
  • Equality ensures that freedom does not become license, and it must be applied across legal, political, social, and economic spheres.
  • R.H. Tawney (in Equality, 1938) argued that absolute liberty is incompatible with economic, social, civil, and political equality.
  • Equality does not dilute liberty but makes it more relevant and substantive.
  • Equality is meant to prevent certain sections of society from acquiring unlimited wealth, power, or prestige, addressing exploitation.
  • Exploitation is a form of social oppression where the stronger party takes undue advantage of the weaker party's position.
  • Liberty and equality both arise from similar logic and serve the same social purpose, aiming to ensure fairness and prevent exploitation.
Members-only content

Unlock this section

Required Membership:Political Science Book Notes OR All Subject Book Notes OR UGC NET + Book Notes OR CUET PG + Book Notes

Membership access will unlock this section automatically.

You cannot copy content of this page

Scroll to Top