The Discipline of Neuropsychology
Chapter – 1
WHAT IS NEUROPSYCHOLOGY?
- The human brain is a remarkable organ responsible for monitoring and controlling basic life support systems, maintaining posture, receiving and interpreting information, storing memories, problem-solving, communication, creativity, and emotional experiences.
- Despite its complexity, the brain can perform multiple functions simultaneously.
- Understanding the brain’s capabilities and mechanisms is a challenging task for contemporary science.
- Significant progress has been made in neuroscience over the past few decades, leading to a growing confidence among neuroscientists in achieving a deeper understanding of brain function.
- Neuropsychology, a specialized field within psychology, focuses on the relationship between the brain and behavior.
- Neuropsychologists aim to explain how brain activity manifests in observable behavior, including thinking, learning, and emotion.
- Investigating the brain’s role in behavior is essential for a comprehensive understanding of psychology, as physiological processes significantly influence human conduct.
- Understanding brain function is crucial for individuals with brain injuries or diseases and has broader implications for medical practice.
BRANCHES OF NEUROPSYCHOLOGY
- Neuropsychology is divided into clinical neuropsychology and experimental neuropsychology.
- Clinical neuropsychology focuses on patients with brain lesions caused by disease, tumors, physical trauma, biochemical changes, or surgical interventions.
- Clinical neuropsychologists assess deficits in intelligence, personality, and sensory-motor functions using specialized testing procedures.
- They relate the results of these tests to specific areas of the brain affected by lesions.
- Behavioral neurology, a subset of clinical neuropsychology, emphasizes conceptual definitions of behavior and individual cases rather than group statistics.
- Studies in behavioral neurology often explore broader aspects of behavior compared to clinical neuropsychology.
- The distinction between clinical neuropsychology and behavioral neurology can be blurred, influenced by historical traditions and practices in different countries.
- Experimental neuropsychologists study normal subjects with intact brains.
- This field has grown rapidly since the 1960s with the development of techniques to study higher brain functions in the laboratory.
- Experimental neuropsychology shares similarities with general experimental and cognitive psychology in terms of laboratory methods.
- Subjects perform tasks while their accuracy or speed of response is recorded, allowing inferences about brain organization to be made.
- Associated variables such as psychophysiological or electrophysiological measures may also be recorded during experiments.
COMPARATIVE NEUROPSYCHOLOGY
- Experimental neuropsychology has historically involved studies with animals, although this approach is now declining.
- Animal studies allowed precise lesions to be introduced into the brain, which could then be confirmed by histology.
- Changes in animal behavior resulting from experimental lesions were observed and correlated with brain alterations.
- Ethical issues aside, working with animals provided advantages such as controlled experiments and histological verification of brain changes.
- However, studying high-level functions like language in animals is limited, making generalization to human brains challenging.
- Basic differences in cortical tissue amount and distribution between animals and humans complicate generalization from animal studies.
- Animal studies remain important, especially for understanding subcortical systems involved in basic aspects of sensation, perception, learning, memory, and emotion.
- Subcortical systems are more challenging to study in humans due to the potential for radical interference with behavior and higher risk of mortality.
- Integrating the study of cortical functions and higher-level behaviors in humans with the study of subcortical structures and basic behavioral systems in animals is a current challenge in neuropsychology.
- There are signs of increasing integration between studies of cortical and subcortical systems, as intelligence and other behaviors are now viewed in terms of underlying basic processes understood from animal studies.
- Areas such as sexual behavior are only open to experimental study in animals but must be understood within the context of socialized and cognitively controlled behavior in humans.
CONCEPTUAL ISSUES
- Neuropsychological investigation relies on inference rather than direct observation of brain states, based on behavioral measures and background information.
- Electrophysiological studies and advanced scanning techniques allow for direct observation of brain states in “real time,” enhancing the importance of these methods in neuropsychology.
- The mind-body problem poses a fundamental philosophical challenge in neuropsychology, concerning the relationship between mental events (mind) and physiological events (body).
- The debate over whether mind and body are fundamentally different kinds of things has persisted for centuries, with no resolution.
- Most neuropsychologists adhere to the position of emergent materialism or emergent psychoneural monism, rejecting the idea of fundamental differences between mind and body.
- Emergent materialism proposes that all mental states are states of the brain, viewing mental events as emergent properties of the brain’s biosystem.
- Mental states cannot be reduced to purely physical states due to the brain’s unique properties as a biosystem, resulting in emergent properties such as thinking, feeling, and perceiving.
- Just as the sweetness of an apple emerges from the interaction of its components with the eater, mental activities emerge from the brain’s structure and environment.
- Neuropsychology must consider both lower-level physiological and biochemical explanations and higher-level concepts concerning emergent properties for a comprehensive understanding of brain function.
- While philosophical issues may not always be at the forefront of neuropsychological work, they imply a certain position that can impact investigations and theoretical models.
- Understanding the implications of one’s philosophical position is essential for a satisfactory understanding of brain function in neuropsychology.
HISTORICAL BACKGROUND
- Neuropsychological study has historical roots dating back to ancient civilizations, with evidence of interest in brain trauma and trepanation.
- In classical Greece, there was an early interest in the brain’s functions, though Greek ideas did not prominently influence Western medieval thought.
- The Renaissance saw advancements in human anatomy, leading to accurate descriptions of the brain’s anatomy by the 19th century.
- Factors contributing to modern neuropsychology include understanding the cortex’s role in intelligent behavior, mapping sensory and motor pathways, and identifying brain regions responsible for language abilities.
- Phrenology, founded in the 1830s, proposed that mental faculties corresponded to specific areas of the brain, although its hypotheses were ultimately dismissed.
- Broca’s 1861 discovery of speech production’s brain localization and subsequent studies of cortical lesions marked the beginning of intensive brain-behavior mapping.
- Localizationist theory assigned specific functions to precise brain locations but faced challenges from equipotential theory, which suggested that the brain’s extent of damage, not location, determined deficits.
- Interactionist theory, influenced by Hughlings Jackson, proposes that higher functions arise from basic component skills distributed throughout the brain.
- Clinical neuropsychology in the 20th century saw advances in understanding brain-behavior relationships through clinical reports and research investigations.
- World Wars I and II provided impetus for neuropsychological research, refining theoretical positions and psychological descriptions.
- Contemporary clinical neuropsychology is based on examining discrete psychological deficits and employing test batteries to assess various behavioral functions.
- Experimental neuropsychology emerged from general experimental psychology, particularly cognitive psychology, and the study of split-brain patients in the 1960s.
- Split-brain operations enabled the study of cerebral specialization, leading to the establishment of experimental neuropsychology as a significant field in modern psychology.
CLINICAL NEUROPSYCHOLOGY
- Clinical neuropsychology primarily relies on established correlations between brain damage and specific psychological deficits, assessed through various psychological tests.
- Different historical traditions have influenced the practice of clinical neuropsychology, with notable traditions in North America, the former Soviet Union, and Great Britain.
- North American clinical neuropsychology emphasizes systematic assessment using standardized tests, often based on psychological models of human abilities.
- The Halstead-Reitan Neuropsychological Test Battery is a widely used assessment tool in North America, covering various psychological abilities.
- Russian neuropsychology employs a single-case study approach, focusing on cerebral organization theories and using informal tests alongside psychophysiological measures.
- British neuropsychology blends standardized procedures with pragmatic test selection, often focusing on discrete performance aspects and individual case investigation.
- The British approach emphasizes the individual nature of each case while using standardized procedures for assessment.
- The clinical skill and insight of the investigator are crucial in all approaches to clinical neuropsychology, with a strong element of scientific detective work involved.
- Clinical neuropsychology remains relevant in diagnosing and localizing brain lesions, despite advancements in medical imaging techniques.
- Neuropsychologists contribute to the rehabilitation of brain-injured patients by providing accurate descriptions of psychological deficits and formulating coherent plans based on the brain’s neuropsychological organization.
EXPERIMENTAL NEUROPSYCHOLOGY
- Experimental neuropsychology encompasses methods relying on stimulus presentation logic, lateral asymmetries in human performance, and specialized techniques.
- Stimulus presentation methods include divided visual field presentation, dichotic listening, and lateralized tactile presentation, exploiting contralateral mapping of sensory input to the brain hemispheres.
- These methods allow for the study of asymmetries in performance, indicating cerebral hemisphere specializations for different types of information and cognitive tasks.
- Performance asymmetries such as lateral eye movements, direction of preferred movement, and handedness have also been linked to hemisphere specialization.
- Research into handedness reveals differences in brain organization between right and left handers, with left handers generally exhibiting less lateralized brains.
- Specialized techniques like the Wada test involve injecting sodium amytal to suppress brain activity temporarily in one hemisphere, providing insights into brain functions.
- Studies of regional cerebral blood flow (rCBF) and metabolic processes track radioactively labeled gas inhaled by subjects, revealing active brain regions during mental tasks.
- Electrophysiological variables, such as ongoing EEG and average evoked potentials, offer opportunities to observe brain activity concurrently with psychological events, though with technical challenges and limited resolution.
- Despite advancements, electrophysiology has yet to fulfill its anticipated potential for providing insights into the relationship between brain and psychological processes.
COGNITIVE NEUROPSYCHOLOGY
- Cognitive neuropsychology emerged in the 1970s as a distinct sub-branch of neuropsychology, characterized by a formalized integration of cognitive psychology and neuropsychology.
- There has been a productive interchange between cognitive psychology and neuropsychology, with cognitive models informing neuropsychological analysis and vice versa.
- In cognitive neuropsychology, cognitive models are developed based on neuropsychological data, and these models are utilized to analyze clinical neuropsychological problems.
- One highly developed example is the model for single word reading, where neuropsychological reading disorders are understood in terms of faults in specific component processes or their connections.
- Cognitive neuropsychology distinguishes between “hard” and “soft” forms, with the former purely focusing on psychological analysis without reference to brain anatomy, while the latter considers neurological organization to some extent.
- Despite the influence of cognitive neuropsychology on shaping neuropsychology over the past 30 years, particularly successful models have made relatively little impact in clinical practice.
- The contribution of cognitive neuropsychology lies more in research and theoretical development than in the development of practical tools and procedures for clinical use.
THE FRINGE
- Neuropsychology has seen the emergence of fringe elements, particularly due to its recent popularity.
- Hemisphere lateralization has sparked theories about consciousness, cultural differences, and occupational and educational adjustment.
- Some suggest that consciousness originated from processes in the right hemisphere associated with the “voice of gods.”
- The development of societal differences among primitive cultures is attributed to variations in the specialization of the cerebral hemispheres.
- It is proposed that Eastern and Western styles of thought reflect lateral differences in brain function.
- “Hemisphericity” is believed to influence occupational success, with questionnaires designed to measure this balance.
- Proposals for changes in educational curricula aim to enhance the supposedly more creative aspects of right-hemisphere function.
- While these ideas are stimulating, they often lack scientific evidence and could be harmful if integrated into cultural or social policies.
- Students are encouraged to critically evaluate these ideas and their implications after studying relevant literature on neuropsychology.
THE PLAN OF THIS BOOK
- The chapter following this overview provides a brief insight into brain structure for readers unfamiliar with neuroanatomy.
- Part II of the book focuses on clinical studies, divided by main regions of the cortex and including sections on language and subcortical systems.
- Building an integrated scheme that maps psychological processes onto anatomical brain systems is essential in studying neuropsychology.
- Approaching studies by anatomical structures or psychological functions both have advantages and disadvantages.
- Presenting material based on anatomical classification may facilitate easier integration across functional categories.
- Part III covers principal areas of experimental neuropsychology, categorized by investigation techniques, with reference to clinical findings.
- The final section explores practical applications of neuropsychology and anticipates future advances in translating research into clinical techniques.
- Neuropsychology presents fascinating conceptual, theoretical, and practical challenges with many mysteries yet to be unraveled.
- Ongoing dramatic developments in neuropsychology promise further insights into the workings of the brain.
- The author hopes that readers embarking on the study of neuropsychology will find it as fascinating and exciting as they do.
CONCLUSION
- Neuropsychology comprises two main branches: clinical neuropsychology and experimental neuropsychology.
- Clinical neuropsychology, including behavioral neurology, focuses on patients with cerebral lesions and has three historical traditions: North American, former Soviet Union, and British.
- Experimental neuropsychology studies normal subjects in the laboratory using various techniques like dichotic listening, divided visual field, and lateralized tactile presentation, along with specialized physiological methods.
- Comparative neuropsychology involves studying the brains of animals, making a distinct but significant contribution to the field.
- Neuropsychology raises fundamental conceptual issues such as the mind-body problem.
- Emergent materialism or emergent psychoneural monism is the generally accepted position in neuropsychology, positing that mental states emerge from brain states but cannot be reduced to single cell properties.
- Modern neuropsychology traces its origins to the latter half of the 19th century.
- Early theoretical positions in neuropsychology included localizationist and equipotential theories.
- Most contemporary neuropsychologists adhere to interactionist theory, which suggests that higher mental functions emerge from interactions among various brain regions, coupled with the concept of regional equipotentiality.